Peanut Butter Pie Ice Cream Pops – if the spoon fits

Usually after I go radio silent within the ice cream blogosphere, I usually have fairly lame excuses…issues like IBS (Irritable Blogger Syndrome), incapability to attain a wholesome work-life steadiness, basic blogger laziness, a busy social calendar, or most of the time, an obsessive Sort A persona that makes it unimaginable to really get pleasure from my creative hobbies on account of paralyzing self-doubt and agonizing consideration to element.

Properly weblog associates, for as soon as my absence has been well-warranted as I’m right here to share not one however TWO main life updates with you all:

1) We purchased a home!


For these of you who’ve been following the weblog for a while, you recognize we’ve been in search of a home for FOREVER as a result of I had a really particular “imaginative and prescient” in thoughts (learn: unrealistic expectations) and I’m excited to announce that we’ve lastly discovered the ONE.

After 5 years of looking out.

And he or she’s a beaut!

However she’s additionally a ton of labor (you tried to warn us, however we didn’t hear).

And likewise..


This information clearly considerably trumps the primary (therefore the all-caps, which is probably the most fast mechanism via which I can appropriately painting my sheer delight and pleasure). Child Spoon might be becoming a member of us in November of this 12 months and we actually couldn’t be any happier/extra terrified/anxious/and so on. (<enter varied curler coaster of feelings right here>).

The very first thing individuals do after they discover out that you simply’re pregnant (apart from make bizarre undesirable feedback about your physique) is ask about your present cravings. For the primary few weeks of the being pregnant I intensely desired waffles, however that’s not essentially one thing that un-pregnant me wouldn’t need on a regular basis anyhow. Nonetheless, I adopted my coronary heart (and my abdomen), and it resulted on this superb recipe from some time again – who knew these breakfast cravings have been really Child Boy at only a few weeks previous, wreaking havoc on my hormonal steadiness!

(Truly I did know, simply kidding. And folks say I’m horrible at preserving secrets and techniques).

My waffle section was enjoyable but short-lived, as a result of at Week 6 the nausea hit, and I wasn’t actually craving a lot of something apart from plain toast with somewhat butter after I was feeling wild. As a bonafide foodie (aka somebody who likes to eat all of the issues on a regular basis), you’ll be able to think about how disappointing this all should have been. I’ve been ready my complete life to be pregnant merely for the additional caloric consumption, and now swiftly I used to be sipping ginger tea and glowing water like my life relied on it.

I began to return out on the opposite facet round Week 18, though it took me just a few further weeks to get again to my regular self. Then at some point in Week 21, it was like somebody flipped a swap in my mind and all I wished was Mexican meals…and peanut butter pie.

As a great midwestern American, peanut butter of any variety has all the time been prevalent in my food regimen. I’ve such a keenness for peanut butter desserts specifically, and peanut butter pie is one in every of my favorites as a result of it actually permits the peanut butter to be the star of the present. So usually, peanut butter will get downgraded to an afterthought – it’s all the time peanut butter AND one thing else – however not with this dessert.

I didn’t have a lot endurance to make a whole pie (though to be clear I may have eaten a complete one on my own), so I made these pops as an alternative.

This can be a quite simple recipe that comes along with  only a few fundamental recipes that you could be have already got in your fridge or pantry. In truth, the toughest half was pulling them out of the popsicle molds because the fats content material makes them a bit comfortable. I tried these before everything in an old school popsicle mildew, however lacked the endurance for a profitable follow-through. I obtained distracted by a renegade spider in my kitchen and held them below scorching water for too lengthy, leading to a considerably melty consequence. They tasted nice and all, however weren’t precisely what I wished (who needs a popsicle that’s already comfortable on its sides?).

Then, I had sufficient sense to tug out my trusty Zoku Fast Pop Maker, which produced 9 pops in round 20 minutes or so and I didn’t have to fret in regards to the mess or disappointment of the quaint popsicle mildew. The Zoku is honestly top-of-the-line, most fulfilling purchases we’ve ever made, and I’m excited to consider how we’ll be capable of use it all through Child Spoon’s childhood to make him home made treats (as a result of taking good care of a child is simple and never time consuming in any respect so I’ll most likely be bored and wish to make all of his meals from scratch, proper?)

No Zoku? No drawback! Simply be sure you have endurance as you pull the frozen pops out of their molds (not like me!), and comply with finest practices – submerge your molds in heat (not scorching) water for 20 to 30 seconds to loosen the edges and gingerly pull them from the grasps of the mildew. Place them on a parchment lined baking sheet or plate within the freezer whilst you proceed to take away the remaining pops.

As a of completion, I drizzled these pops with chocolate and crushed cookies to amp up the pie sentiment. Remember the fact that you may as well combine cookies into the precise pop combination and freeze all of it collectively, however as a result of I wished a lovelier presentation (you recognize, Instagram and all that) I selected to make use of them as a finisher on high of a chocolate drizzle – as a result of NOTHING is extra lovely than a chocolate drizzle.

I additionally like to combine my cookies with somewhat butter beforehand so it tastes extra like crust, however in case you do combine them into your base I’d recommend leaving the butter out – it’s an additional step that seemingly gained’t have an enormous taste payoff ultimately (you’ll barely be capable of discover the butter in opposition to all that creamy peanut-y goodness).

These pops are candy and savory, and excellent for anybody who loves peanut butter (not to mention its delectable pie counter half).

I hope you’re keen on this easy pop recipe that’s a summer-approved model of an all time favourite dessert. In truth, I’ll most likely eat them within the fall and winter too (however who’s preserving observe?).

Comfortable scooping!

Peanut Butter Pie Ice Cream Pops

 Yield: 9 Pops


1 cup clean creamy peanut butter (ideally not pure or no-stir)

1 bundle cream cheese, softened (eight ounces)

1/three cup powdered sugar

2 cups milk (a fuller fats milk like 2% and even complete milk is finest)

Pinch of salt

12 chocolate sandwich cookies

1 tablespoon butter

Scorching fudge or chocolate syrup for adorning (try my home made scorching fudge right here)

Just a few tablespoons of whipped topping or whipped cream (elective)


Make the Pie Pops

  1. Utilizing an electrical mixer, whisk collectively peanut butter and cream cheese till clean, about 1 to 2 minutes.
  2. Add in powdered sugar, and whisk for about 30 extra seconds, or till mixed.
  3. Utilizing a low setting, stir within the milk, 1 cup at a time. Stir till clean and every little thing is mixed. (Please word: in lieu of an electrical mixer, you’ll be able to undoubtedly use your individual energy and a picket spoon to combine this collectively, you’ll simply get somewhat little bit of a piece out :)).
  4. Spoon pie pop combination into your Zoku Fast Pop Maker or a conventional ice pop mildew. If utilizing the Zoku, make all of your pops without delay and place on a parchment-lined baking sheet or plates within the freezer till your decorations are ready. If utilizing conventional technique, permit a full 5 or 6 hours to freeze, then take away mildew from freezer and submerge sides of the mildew into heat water for 20 to 30 seconds. Slowly and gently take away pops from mildew, and place them on a baking sheet or plate lined with parchment paper till prepared to brighten.

Make your Decorations

  1. Crush up cookies, utilizing a rolling pin or backside of a heavy consuming glass (or you’ll be able to go excessive tech and use the heart beat setting on a blender or meals processor).
  2. Stir in melted butter, and sprinkle with a light-weight sprinkling of salt if desired.
  3. Make scorching fudge or warmth up store-bought fudge till skinny sufficient to spoon onto the pops however not scorching sufficient to soften them.


  1. Drizzle frozen pops with as a lot or as little chocolate sauce as you want.
  2. Sprinkle crushed cookies on high and calmly press down with a spoon to make sure cookie crumbs persist with the chocolate.
  3. Set baking sheet or plate into the freezer till chocolate sauce is ready, about half an hour.
  4. You might also dip into whipped topping, if desired.
  5. Will be saved as much as per week within the freezer.


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.