Dark Chocolate Chunk Guinness Ice Cream Sandwiches – if the spoon fits


7 years in the past, on the tender age of 23, I fell in love with an Irishman.

(Or a minimum of, somebody whom I assumed was an Irishman).

All of the telltale indicators had been there: crimson hair, crimson beard, very Irish-sounding final identify, above-average capacity to recall Irish proverbs, and most significantly, might drink me below the desk any evening of the week.

(Expensive people who find themselves really from Eire: I understand these are all very generalized statements which can be mildly to reasonably offensive and culturally insensitive, so apologies upfront for my indiscretions).


So, I married mentioned man, and we’ve had an exquisite, lovely life collectively. Fortunately ever after, some would say.

Besides…it was all a lie.


Seems, I didn’t marry an Irishman in any respect. Slightly, I married your typical, run of the mill, little-bit-Irish-but-really-mostly-British-and-Jap-European midwestern white man.

In my husband’s protection, he had no thought. The truth is, nobody in his household had any thought. Till sooner or later, when his brother bought a type of mail-order DNA kits, and the reality was revealed: my tremendous Irish household turned out to be…nicely, simply kinda Irish.


Since phrase of this earth-shattering realization, it’s been a tough few months – however we’re all working via it collectively, similar to households do! (These scrumptious, booze-filled ice cream sandwiches are actually serving to us begin the therapeutic).


One other silver lining? St. Patty’s Day is simply across the nook, and whether or not your organic make-up helps it or not, everybody is Irish on St. Patty’s Day!


I can’t consider a greater approach to pay homage to my household’s imagined heritage than 1) booze and a couple of) darkish fudgy cookies. These sandwiches are completely unimaginable, and miles higher than these retailer purchased ones they used to offer us in elementary college (no shade thrown right here – these are wonderful in their very own proper, however don’t maintain a deal with to those infants).


I’ll be upfront with you: making ice cream sandwiches from scratch isn’t any joke, however don’t fear – it’s nothing we will’t do collectively! My humble recommendation is to give attention to the ice cream first, since we all know that basically wants about 24 hours from begin to end.

(Facet observe: as soon as I make my custard base, I prefer to refrigerate it in a single day or for someplace within the neighborhood of 6 to eight hours to verify it’s good and chilly earlier than churning. Then, when you churn the ice cream and switch to your storage container, I like to recommend storing the ice cream in a single day or for a full eight hours to offer it some a lot wanted magnificence relaxation; aka, give it time to freeze totally. That is particularly necessary with this ice cream – because of the excessive alcohol content material, the ice cream will take longer to develop into stable).


For the ice cream, I used further stout, however you should utilize any number of guinness (or actually, any darkish beer). This tremendous darkish model lended a pleasant, virtually coffee-like bitterness that stood up confidently in opposition to the cream and eggs, however was additionally a beautiful complement to our chocolate cookies.

The trick to beer-infused ice cream is to make use of a whole bottle, however prepare dinner half of it till it reduces and turns barely syrupy. Due to all of the liquid we’re utilizing, the feel of the completed product is a bit icier than my regular custard-based ice lotions, nevertheless it’s good in opposition to the backdrop of the chewy fudgy cookies.


Talking of cookies, you should utilize no matter cookie recipe you want, however this one is fairly particular – as a result of the recipe incorporates extra sugar than chocolate, these cookies keep good and chewy (versus crumbly or rock laborious) when frozen – ensuing within the good ice cream sandwich chew: chocolate chunks that snap delightfully, chewy cookie that fights again however received’t break your tooth, and a barely bitter-but-in-a-good-way Guinness ice cream refreshment. A contact of sea salt provides a savory complexity and completely rounds out the entire expertise.


For those who’re planning a get-together, you may make all of the elements a day or so upfront, which could be very useful in lowering any prep-related stress the day that you just plan to serve these (St. Patty’s Day Occasion, maybe?).


Concerning ice cream sandwich greatest practices, I want I had extra recommendation to offer! However a couple of basic guidelines of thumb:

  • Freeze your cookies for an hour or two upfront of meeting, so that they develop a little bit of a spine and you may manhandle them with out worrying you’ll break them
  • When scooping the ice cream, be sure to create good rounded scoops with a number of quantity within the middle of the inside track. This ensures that if you shut the sandwich, you get rounded edges which can be each visually interesting and assure a little bit of ice cream in each single chew.
  • When assembling, be sure that the ice cream is delicate and scoopable. When closing the sandwich collectively, don’t press too terribly laborious or else the cookie might break within the center (however freezing the cookies upfront will assist cut back this danger).
  • For storage, I at all times wrap my ice cream sandwiches in a number of layers of plastic wrap individually, after which freeze them in a storage container all collectively. The plastic wrap ought to maintain the sandwiches recent for as much as every week, however the added barrier of the Tupperware retains any undesirable frostiness from creeping inside and degrading our taste.

Irish or not, I feel you’ll love these tremendous superior, extremely tasty, undeniably festive ice cream sandwiches which can be good on your St. Patty’s Day gathering (whether or not that’s an precise gathering, or simply consuming pizza and watching on Nextflix).


Completely satisfied scooping 🙂

Darkish Chocolate Chunk Guinness Ice Cream Sandwiches

Yield: About 12 Sandwiches


Ice Cream:

12 ounces (1 bottle) of Guinness (I used Overseas Additional Stout)

1 tsp of vanilla extract

6 giant egg yolks

2 cups of heavy cream

three/four cup of white sugar

1/2 tsp of salt


(cookie recipe tailored from the Bojon Gourmand)

6 tbsp unsalted butter

10 ounces darkish or bittersweet chocolate, chopped (1 and three/four cups) plus further chunks for the tops of the cookies

1/2 cup plus 2 tablespoons flour

three/four teaspoon baking powder

2 giant eggs (at room temp)

three/four cup sugar

1/2 tsp kosher salt

1 tsp vanilla extract

Flaky sea salt to complete



  1. Preheat oven to 350 and line rimless cookie sheet with parchment paper.
  2. In a small saucepan over low warmth, soften the butter gently till fully liquid. Then add in 1 cup of the chocolate, and stir continuously till fully melted. Take away from warmth and put aside.
  3. In a separate mixing bowl, sift collectively the flour and baking powder and put aside.
  4. Place eggs, sugar, and salt within the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment and beat on medium-high till the batter triples in quantity and could be very mild and ethereal, virtually mousse-y (about 5 minutes).
  5. Flip the mixer to low and stir within the vanilla and melted chocolate (taking care the chocolate is barely lukewarm, not scorching). Stir till simply mixed, then add within the flour and beat on low velocity till simply mixed. The batter ought to appear to be brownie batter.
  6. Fold within the remaining three/four cup chopped chocolate.
  7. Drop heaping tablespoons of batter onto your ready pan, permitting a minimum of 2 inches in between every cookie. High every cookie with sea salt and additional chocolate chunks, if desired.
  8. Bake till the tops are puffed and cracked, round 10 to 12 minutes. Let cool for a couple of minutes on the recent pans after which switch to a cooling rack.
  9. As soon as fully cooled, place cookies in a storage container and freeze for one to 2 hours (if time permits) earlier than you begin assembling your sandwiches.

Ice Cream:

  1. In a medium skillet, warmth half of the beer over medium warmth. Prepare dinner till decreased by half (about 15 minutes) or till the beer turns into syrupy. As soon as decreased, mix with the remainder of the beer in a big glass or liquid measuring cup. Add the vanilla extract, stir, and put aside.
  2. In a medium bowl, flippantly break up egg yolks with a whisk. Put aside.
  3. In a medium saucepan, mix heavy cream, sugar, and salt. Warmth till the granules of sugar are melted and the combination simply begins to steam (however don’t enable it to boil).
  4. Add the heated cream combination to the egg yolks, a bit at a time, whisking the egg yolks continuously (you don’t need scrambled eggs!).
  5. As soon as the entire heated cream has been added to the yolks, add the combination again to the pot. Prepare dinner over medium warmth, stirring continuously with a warmth proof spatula or wood spoon. After about ten minutes, the combination will thicken (you’ll really feel it begin to “push again” in opposition to your spoon). As soon as the combination covers the spoon, however leaves a transparent path if you wipe your finger throughout, your custard is finished!
  6. Pour the custard via the sieve and into the bowl. That is the place you’ll add your remaining beer! Stir to mix, and refridgerate combination for four hours or ideally, overight.
  7. Freeze ice cream in your ice cream maker in keeping with producer’s directions.  Switch to an hermetic storage container in a single day, or for about eight hours, making certain it has sufficient time to freeze fully earlier than you try and construct your sandwiches.


  1. Take away ice cream from freezer and permit to melt for five to 10 minutes, or till simply scoopable. Within the meantime, line cookie sheets with parchment paper.
  2. Line your cookies up on baking sheets in pairs, trying to maintain similarly-sized cookies collectively.
  3. Scoop ice cream on prime of 1 facet of every cookie, then gently press them collectively, taking care to not crush or smoosh your cookie.
  4. As soon as assembled, place sandwiches within the freezer and permit to harden for 20 minutes earlier than serving.
  5. If not serving instantly, place uncovered sandwiches within the freezer for about an hour to harden. Then, wrap every particular person sandwich in plastic wrap (I prefer to double wrap). Place ice cream sandwiches in an hermetic storage container all collectively. Ought to maintain for about 2 to three weeks.
  6. Take pleasure in 🙂


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.